Back

Mind the Gap

gender_pay_gap

ChapmanCG’s Paul Jury and other business leaders speak about gender pay gaps across various industries in this Institute of Managers and Leaders (IML) summary of the Gender Pay Gap Report. For the original article, click here.  

The latest IML Gender Pay Report reveals that if you’re a female working in a C-Suite role, you could be earning as much as 15% less than your male colleagues.

The report presents findings based on an analysis of pay differentials from 2014-2018 between male and female full-time employees within the Australian workforce. The research considers different employment levels and job families ranging from administration to general management. The analysis uses IML’s National Salary Survey, updated in October 2018, and data collected from 460 organisations across Australia, covering more than 250 job roles.

The research doesn’t reflect casual or part-time workers, or maternity leave which explains differences between the IML report and the gaps reported by government organisations such as Workplace Gender Equality Agency (WGEA), according to report author, Sam Bell FIML, General Manager, Corporate Services and Research, IML. The full-time total remuneration gender pay gap based on WGEA data is 22.4%, meaning men working full time earn, on average, nearly $27,000 a year more than women working full time.

Why the gap persists

According to the IML report, the C-Suite pay gap fell to 9.8% three years ago after a high of 14.7% in 2014. But over the past three years, the gender pay gap for C-Suite roles climbed steadily and is now approaching the levels of five years ago. Bell explains that isolating the reasons for the widening gap at the C-Suite level is challenging. “There are probably more female managers in lower-paying industries. However, our research measures like-against-like job levels and job families, so more female executives working in lower paid industries doesn’t explain the C-Suite gap thoroughly.

“That there is a 14.6% difference in like-against-like general manager salaries is certainly an eye-opening statistic that organisations need to review.”

Libby Lyons, Director of the WGEA, says, “The gender pay gap is a symptom of a broader issue. It reflects the fact that women’s work is traditionally undervalued, and women are often paid less than men.

“As a nation, we need to be talking about what is behind the gender pay gap – the barriers women face in the workplace that cause the gender pay gap.”

Where the gap is closing

If you’re seeking work in an industry with closer to equal pay, then look no further than information technology (4.6%) and engineering and science (4.8%). That said, in 2014 the IT pay gap slightly favoured women (-0.1%), and the difference was only 0.3% for females working in engineering and science. On the flipside, the salary gap for women in finance and accounting improved from 13.7% down to 7.1% over the past four years.

IT continuously rates well for women’s pay rates because it’s a result driven industry that typically doesn’t differentiate between male or female employees, notes Bell. “The salary gaps in finance and accounting have dropped because there is greater awareness of gender diversity issues in that profession because of CEOs such as former Westpac boss Gail Kelly.

“That industry was heavily male-dominated, but with high-profile CEOs like Kelly championing the issue and taking it head-on, the pay gap almost halved in the past four years.”

Addressing the gap

Paul Jury, Managing Director of Australia for global HR executive search firm ChapmanCG, resolutely believes there should be no excuses for gender pay gaps. He elaborates, “Moreover, there’s plenty of research indicating that up to 70% of employers report they have policies in place to support gender equality.

“With the gender pay gap, it is all heading in the right direction, but the speed of improvement is still too slow.”

Personal biases can come into play particularly where objective measures of performance are deficient and create incidences of gender gaps in promotions and pay, reasons Jury. “For senior roles, some managers without access to objective data may tend to promote and reward people they like and whom they perceive are more like them.

“While unconscious bias is hard to rewire, more training, education, and awareness within an organisation can help to mitigate its impact on gender diversity, promotion and pay. This includes putting in place guidelines, along with checks and balances within a business to minimise the gender pay gap.”

Bell agrees more investment in educating managers about gender equality issues is required. “Educating managers who hire staff that pay gaps are not acceptable is a start,” he reasons. “And the fact that skills, experience, and qualifications should be paid for, irrespective of whether a recruit is male or female.”

From a leadership perspective, Bell believes an organisation should have a gender pay gap policy or statement in place that all managers “understand and take seriously”. WGEA research indicates that actions to correct like-for-like gender pay gaps are three times as effective in reducing overall pay inequities when combined with reporting to executives and boards. Bell says, “There’s a lot of large Australian companies that are certainly taking all these steps. All of them probably have a statement from a leadership level, whether it’s CEO down, saying that pay gaps won’t be tolerated.”

Accountability counts

Using market data such as IML’s National Salary Survey is another prudent step towards minding the pay gap says Bell. “Employers must understand what the market is paying for a C-Suite role or line manager and it shouldn’t matter whether someone is male or female.”

Another critical way to strengthen employer accountability would be to end pay secrecy, according to Alice Orchiston, an Associate Lecturer in Law at the University of Sydney. To this end the federal Australian Labor Party announced in September last year that, if elected, it will legislate for the introduction of publicly available company-specific gender pay gap data. In an opinion piece for academic journal The Conversation, Orchiston wrote: “If women discover they are earning less than their male counterparts for the same jobs, their legal avenues for pursuing equal pay are limited. It’s difficult to prove and costly to litigate.”

Orchiston continued, “Requiring employers to make their pay records publicly accessible or accessible to employees across the same organisation would create greater transparency and a basis for women to assess their pay, which in turn could facilitate negotiation or legal action.”

Read the full report

The IML 2018 Gender Pay Gap report can be purchased at managersandleaders.com.au/national-salary-survey

Original article written by Anthony O’Brien, https://managersandleaders.com.au/blog/mind-the-gap/, Feb 2019

To keep up with the latest HR trends, subscribe to our quarterly newsletter, or visit our News page.

You can also check out our latest global HR opportunities, or contact our consulting team to discuss your search needs.

Newsletter

Keep up with all the latest HR insights and updates.
Sign up

Related Posts

Key Contributors:

Paul Jury

Managing Director

Consulting Team
View more
Consulting Team

Paul Jury

Managing Director

Paul is a Managing Director with ChapmanCG based in Australia, and is a member of the organisation’s global leadership team. He holds responsibility for people and performance across the Asia Pacific region, and he works with a dynamic team across the company’s developed markets of Singapore, Hong Kong, China, Japan, Korea, Taiwan, Australia and New Zealand. Paul also takes a hands-on approach to building ChapmanCG’s business and brand in Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia and the Philippines.

Before joining the ChapmanCG team, Paul spent eight years at Talent2 International as Managing Director of the recruitment business across Australasia, where he also served as a member of the global recruitment team. Prior to this he held various senior management roles with TMP Worldwide (NASDAQ listed) and Morgan & Banks (ASX listed) across Australia and New Zealand.

Originally from Melbourne, Paul has worked in sports management, chartered accounting and advertising. He holds a Bachelor of Business from Chisholm Institute of Technology (now Monash University) and has participated in professional development at the Macquarie Graduate School of Management.

Paul’s personal interests revolve around his young family and trying to stay balanced with his professional and personal life. Paul is an avid lover of sport and has a particular passion for football, cricket and golf.

Latest Articles by Paul

ChapmanCG News 11 March 2019

Steven Watton Joins APAC Team as Senior Director

ChapmanCG is thrilled to announce the appointment of Steven Watton to the role of Senior Director based in…

Paul Jury
Read
Diversity and Inclusion 26 February 2019

Mind the Gap

ChapmanCG’s Paul Jury and other business leaders speak about gender pay gaps across various industries…

Paul Jury
Read
Talent Development 22 December 2018

Harnessing Flexibility and Neuroscience to Drive Performance

Flexible working and neuroscience can both play an important role in driving employee engagement and…

Paul Jury
Read
Talent Development 9 October 2018

100% Human at Work: Shaping a Better Future of Work

ChapmanCG was delighted to support the launch of The B Team in Australia with Sir…

Paul Jury
Read
Talent Acquisition 28 August 2018

The New Skillsets to Future-Proof Your Workforce

New core skillsets for employees will enable HR leaders to help future-proof their businesses and…

Fiona Jury
Read
Global HR Updates 18 June 2018

Global HR Outlook Q3 2018

The global economy continues to perform well, making the outlook for the second half of…

Stefanie Cross-Wilson
Read
Culture & Business Transformation 26 October 2017

The Digital Future of HR

In conjunction with Cisco and EY, ChapmanCG was delighted to host two HR Leaders Discussion…

Fiona Jury
Read
Culture & Business Transformation 10 May 2017

Building High Performance Organisations

In conjunction with Novartis and Unispace, ChapmanCG hosted two HR Leaders Discussion Groups in Sydney…

Fiona Jury
Read
ChapmanCG News 4 November 2016

Why HR and Innovation are the Hottest New Power Couple

The best and most disruptive innovation outcomes occur when the right combination of the right…

Fiona Jury
Read
Culture & Business Transformation 15 December 2015

Influencing Change in Japan: Regional HR Successes and Misconceptions

In early December, ChapmanCG hosted an exceptional meeting for Singapore-based regional HR leaders on the…

Paul Jury
Read